Is TOO FACED Better Than Sex Mascara waterproof?

The standard version is not waterproof, but a waterproof formulation is available separately.

Does this mascara smudge easily?

While many users report good wear, some individuals, especially those with oily eyelids or in humid climates, have experienced smudging.

Most users find that one or two coats are sufficient for significant volume and length. Applying more than two coats can sometimes lead to clumping.

It can be easily removed with most makeup removers, including micellar water or oil-based cleansers, without excessive scrubbing.

Best For: Achieving dramatic lash volume and intensity.
Strengths: Exceptional volume, intense black pigment, noticeable lengthening effect.
Drawbacks: Can be prone to flaking or clumping for some users, may smudge.
Verdict: A staple for bold, voluminous lashes.

Aspect	Pros	Cons
Volume & Length	Users report significant volume and noticeable length, making lashes appear fuller and longer with just one or two coats. Many appreciate the dramatic effect it provides.	Some users find it can lead to clumpy lashes if multiple coats are applied too quickly. A few mention it can be too heavy for a natural look.
Wear & Longevity	Many find it lasts throughout the day without significant fading. It generally holds a curl well for most users.	For some, the mascara is prone to flaking under the eyes, especially after several hours of wear. Others have experienced smudging, particularly in humid conditions or with oily skin.
Application	The hourglass-shaped brush is often praised for effectively coating every lash from root to tip, contributing to the voluminous effect.	The brush can sometimes pick up too much product, requiring careful scraping of the excess to avoid over-application and potential clumping.

Component/Feature	Why It Matters
Hourglass-Shaped Brush	The unique brush shape is designed to mimic the curves of a woman's body, allowing it to hug each lash for maximum coating, lift, and separation, contributing to the volumizing effect.
Collagen-Infused Formula	Formulated with collagen, the mascara aims to plump and moisturize lashes, helping to create a fuller appearance and prevent brittleness.
Film-Forming Polymers	These ingredients help to hold the mascara in place, providing wear and curl retention for extended periods, though some users still experience flaking.

Aspect	Positive	Negative
Performance vs. Price	Users who prioritize dramatic volume and intensity often find the mascara’s performance justifies its higher price point compared to drugstore alternatives, considering the immediate visual impact.	For those seeking a more natural look or experiencing issues like flaking or smudging, the value proposition may decrease, as similar results or better longevity can sometimes be found in less expensive options.
Longevity of Product	A little product goes a long way for achieving significant volume, meaning the tube can last a reasonable amount of time for many users, offering a good number of applications.	Some users report that the formula can dry out faster than expected, making the product less usable before it's fully depleted, which impacts its overall cost efficiency.

Aspect	L'Oréal Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara	Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Mascara	TOO FACED Better Than Sex Volumizing Mascara
Key Features	Soft, feathery volume and intense length; often compared for similar effect at a lower price point.	Significant curl and lift with good separation; creates a wide-eyed look.	Dramatic, intense volume and length; aims for a false-lash effect.
Durability/Wear	Generally good wear, but some report minimal flaking after extended hours.	Excellent curl hold and minimal smudging; very long-lasting.	Good all-day wear for many, but can be prone to flaking and smudging for some skin types or in humid conditions.
Overall Value	High value given its performance, often seen as a premium drugstore option.	Good value for its unique curling capabilities and consistent performance.	Good value for dramatic results if flaking/smudging is not an issue; performance aligns with its prestige price for many users.

Is TOO FACED Better Than Sex Mascara waterproof? The standard version is not waterproof, but a waterproof formulation is available separately.
Does this mascara smudge easily? While many users report good wear, some individuals, especially those with oily eyelids or in humid climates, have experienced smudging.
How many coats are recommended for optimal results? Most users find that one or two coats are sufficient for significant volume and length. Applying more than two coats can sometimes lead to clumping.
Is it easy to remove? It can be easily removed with most makeup removers, including micellar water or oil-based cleansers, without excessive scrubbing.

This mascara truly delivers on volume, making my sparse lashes look incredibly full and long. It’s perfect for a dramatic eye look.
The black pigment is so intense; it makes my eyes pop and really defines my lashes.
I love how much length it adds without making my lashes feel brittle. It’s my go-to for special occasions.
The hourglass brush perfectly coats every lash, and I see a noticeable difference in my lash thickness.
It holds a curl beautifully throughout the day, which is something I struggle to find in other mascaras.

While the volume is great, I find that this mascara tends to flake quite a bit by the end of the day, leaving specks under my eyes.
It can be very clumpy if you’re not careful with application, and sometimes it looks a bit spidery rather than voluminous.
I experience significant smudging, especially on my lower lash line, even if I don't apply it there.
The formula seems to dry out quickly in the tube, making it harder to apply smoothly after a month or so.
For the price, I wish it had better longevity without the flaking issues.

Aspect	Detail
Product Name	TOO FACED Better Than Sex Volumizing Mascara
Volume	Typically 0.27 fl. oz / 8.0 mL (full size)
Color Options	Available primarily in 'Black' (Other limited editions/colors may exist)
Brush Type	Hourglass-shaped fiber brush
Key Ingredients (Highlights)	Collagen, Acacia Senegal Gum (for curl hold)
Cruelty-Free	Yes
Paraben-Free	Yes
Gluten-Free	Yes

The TOO FACED Better Than Sex Volumizing Mascara is a highly popular product known for its ability to deliver dramatic volume and noticeable length, making lashes appear fuller and more intense.
Its unique hourglass-shaped brush is designed to coat every lash, contributing to its impactful performance and intense black finish.
However, potential users should be aware of common user feedback regarding its tendency to flake or smudge for some individuals, particularly after extended wear or in certain conditions.
While it commands a premium price, many find its bold results justify the cost, especially for those seeking a false-lash effect without applying falsies.
If your primary goal is to achieve maximum volume and a striking lash look and you are prepared for potential minor touch-ups or occasional flaking, this mascara could be an excellent addition to your makeup routine. If you prioritize extreme smudge-proof wear or a very natural look, you might consider alternatives.