How should I apply the NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base?

Apply a thin layer to clean, dry eyelids using the wand applicator, then gently blend with a fingertip or brush before applying eyeshadow.

Is this eyeshadow base suitable for oily eyelids?

Yes, it is widely praised for its effectiveness on oily eyelids, helping to absorb oil and prevent creasing and fading.

The NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base dries down to a clear, invisible finish, making it suitable for all skin tones and eyeshadow colors.

It is designed to work effectively with various eyeshadow formulas, including powder, cream, and glitter, enhancing their longevity and vibrancy.

Aspect	Pros	Cons
Longevity	Users consistently report significantly extended eyeshadow wear, often lasting all day without fading.	Some users with very oily eyelids noted it still allowed minor fading after many hours, though less than without a base.
Creasing Prevention	Many reviews highlight its effectiveness in preventing eyeshadow from creasing, even in humid conditions.	A few users with deep-set or very textured eyelids experienced minimal creasing, particularly with heavily emollient eyeshadows.
Application & Feel	The formula is described as smooth, lightweight, and easy to apply, drying down quickly without feeling sticky.	Some found the applicator wand a bit stiff, leading to potential uneven application if not blended thoroughly.
Eyeshadow Enhancement	Users observe that it helps eyeshadows appear more vibrant and true to color on the lid.	A small number of users felt it didn't significantly intensify shimmer or metallic shadows as much as some other primers.

Component/Ingredient Profile	Why It Matters
Lightweight Polymer Blend	Forms a thin, invisible film on the eyelid, creating a smooth surface for eyeshadow adhesion. This helps to extend wear and prevent creasing by providing a non-slippery base.
Mineral Powder	Contributes to oil absorption, helping to keep eyelids dry and eyeshadow fresh throughout the day, especially beneficial for oily skin types.
Wand Applicator	Allows for precise application directly onto the eyelid, minimizing product waste and ensuring an even distribution for optimal performance.

Aspect	Positive	Negative
Performance Per Use	A small amount of product is sufficient for each application, making the tube last for an extended period. Users find its performance justifies the investment per application.	Initial cost may be higher than some drugstore alternatives, which could deter budget-conscious consumers.
Longevity of Product	The formula remains effective over its lifespan, and the packaging helps maintain its integrity, ensuring the product performs consistently until empty.	Some users have reported the product drying out slightly towards the end of the tube, potentially requiring more effort to extract.
Applicator Design	The integrated wand allows for hygienic and controlled application directly to the eyelid, which contributes to efficient product use and less waste.	The narrow opening of the tube can make it challenging to access the last bits of product when the tube is nearing empty, leading to perceived waste.

Aspect	Urban Decay Primer Potion	Too Faced Shadow Insurance	NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base
Key Features	Variety of finishes (original, anti-aging, Eden, Sin), widely recognized for creaseless wear.	Smooth, creamy texture; known for long-lasting wear and vibrant shadow payoff.	Clear, lightweight formula; excels in smudge-proof and crease-proof performance.
Durability	Offers excellent all-day wear, resistant to creasing and fading for most skin types.	Very reliable for extended wear, particularly good at holding onto glitter and shimmer.	Highly effective at maintaining eyeshadow integrity throughout the day, even in humid conditions, often cited for its superior smudge-proofing.
Overall Value	Good value given its performance and popularity; a staple for many makeup users.	Offers strong performance for its price point, a solid choice for longevity.	Considered a premium product that delivers consistent, professional-grade results, justifying its price for those seeking maximum smudge and crease resistance.

How should I apply the NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base?Apply a thin layer to clean, dry eyelids using the wand applicator, then gently blend with a fingertip or brush before applying eyeshadow.
Is this eyeshadow base suitable for oily eyelids?Yes, it is widely praised for its effectiveness on oily eyelids, helping to absorb oil and prevent creasing and fading.
Does this base have a tint or is it clear?The NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base dries down to a clear, invisible finish, making it suitable for all skin tones and eyeshadow colors.
Can it be used with all types of eyeshadows?It is designed to work effectively with various eyeshadow formulas, including powder, cream, and glitter, enhancing their longevity and vibrancy.

This primer makes my eyeshadow last from morning to night without any creasing or fading, even in hot weather.
My eyelids are very oily, and this is the only base that genuinely keeps my eyeshadow looking fresh all day.
It's completely invisible once applied, doesn't feel heavy, and makes my shadows pop more.
A little goes a long way with this product, so the tube lasts a surprisingly long time.
I've tried many primers, but this one truly lives up to its smudge-proof claim, especially for eyeliner.

Towards the end of the tube, it becomes quite difficult to get the product out with the wand, which feels wasteful.
On very dry days, it can feel a little too drying on my eyelids, emphasizing fine lines slightly.
For the price, I expected it to also intensify shimmers more, but it mainly just helps with longevity.
While it prevents creasing, it doesn't always make highly pigmented shadows look significantly brighter on my skin.

Specification	Detail
Product Type	Eyeshadow Primer / Base
Net Weight/Volume	0.26 oz / 7.5 ml
Finish	Matte, invisible
Color	Translucent (dries clear)
Applicator Type	Doe-foot wand
Key Benefits	Smudge-proof, crease-proof, enhances eyeshadow wear, lightweight
Dermatologist-Tested	Yes

The NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base is a highly effective product for anyone seeking to extend the wear of their eyeshadow and prevent creasing.
Its lightweight, clear formula makes it suitable for all skin tones and eyeshadow types, offering a smooth canvas for vibrant color payoff.
Users with oily eyelids particularly benefit from its oil-absorbing properties, ensuring eyeshadow remains fresh throughout the day.
While its initial cost is higher than some alternatives, its efficiency—requiring only a small amount per use—often makes it a cost-effective choice in the long run.
Potential drawbacks include the challenge of accessing the last bits of product.
Overall, if your priority is long-lasting, crease-free eyeshadow and you're willing to invest in a reliable primer, the NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base is a strong contender.