β‘οΈ Quick Verdict - MEDELA Pump In Style Advanced
- Best For: Daily breast milk expression for mothers seeking efficiency and reliability.
- Strengths: Dual-phase expression, consistent suction, widely available parts.
- Drawbacks: Can be noisy, open system design, less portable than some newer models.
- Verdict: A time-tested, dependable option for consistent milk expression.
βοΈ Pros & Cons Explained
| Aspect | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Pumping Efficiency | Users often report effective and quick milk expression due to the 2-Phase Expression technology, mimicking a baby's natural nursing rhythm. | Some users find the fixed suction levels less customizable compared to pumps with more granular settings, potentially leading to less optimal milk output for some individuals. |
| Portability & Design | The pump is designed with a tote or backpack for convenient transport for mothers on the go, and includes a battery pack option for cord-free pumping. | Despite the carrying bag, the unit itself can be bulky and heavier than some compact, modern pumps, making true portability for all situations challenging. |
| Noise Level | While not silent, many users find the noise level manageable for home or office use, especially given its powerful motor. | A common point of feedback is that the motor can be audibly loud during operation, which might be disruptive in quiet environments or during night pumping. |
| Maintenance & Hygiene | The parts that come into contact with milk are relatively simple to disassemble and clean. | It operates on an open-system design, which means milk can potentially enter the tubing or motor if not properly managed, requiring more careful maintenance to ensure hygiene. |
π§ Whatβs Included? & Why It Matters
| Component | Why It Matters |
|---|---|
| Pump Motor Unit | The core of the system, providing the suction for efficient milk expression. Its power and reliability are crucial for consistent pumping. |
| PersonalFit Breast Shields (one standard size) | Properly sized breast shields are essential for comfort and efficient milk flow. While one standard size (typically 24mm) is included, users may need to purchase other sizes separately to find their best fit, which is crucial for reducing discomfort and maximizing output. |
| Breast Milk Bottles with Lids (4x 5oz) | Allows for direct collection and storage of expressed milk, integrating seamlessly with the pump for convenience. |
| Tubing & Connectors | Connects the breast shields to the motor, enabling suction. Intact tubing is vital for maintaining vacuum and pumping efficiency. |
| AC Power Adapter | Provides reliable power for home or office use, ensuring the pump is ready when needed without relying on batteries. |
| Battery Pack (8 AA batteries not included) | Offers mobility and allows for pumping away from a power outlet, providing flexibility for mothers on the go. |
| Stylish Tote Bag or Backpack | Designed to discreetly carry the pump and all its accessories, facilitating transport and organization. |
| Cooler Bag with Ice Pack | Essential for safely transporting expressed breast milk, keeping it cool for several hours. |
π° Is It Worth It? β Value & Cost Efficiency
| Aspect | Positive | Negative |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Investment | Often considered a moderate-to-high upfront investment, but its reputation for durability means it can serve effectively for one or multiple children. | The initial cost can be a barrier for some, especially if not covered by insurance. |
| Durability & Longevity | Many users report the pump motor and components holding up well over extended periods of daily use, making it a reliable long-term tool. | While durable, some accessory parts like tubing or membranes may need periodic replacement, adding to long-term costs. |
| Resale/Hand-me-down Value | Due to its robust build, the pump can retain some value for resale or be passed down, offering further cost efficiency. | As an open system, there are hygiene considerations if purchasing used, which can impact its desirability. |
| Availability of Parts & Support | Replacement parts and customer support are widely available, ensuring the pump remains functional even if a component needs replacing. | Reliance on specific brand-name parts for optimal function can sometimes be more costly than generic alternatives. |
π Medela Comparison β How This Version Improves Over Previous Models
The Medela Pump In Style Advanced introduced Medela's 2-Phase Expression Technology, a significant improvement over earlier models like the original Pump In Style (without Advanced) that operated with only one fixed suction pattern.
| Aspect | Original Medela Pump In Style | Medela Pump In Style Advanced |
|---|---|---|
| Pumping Technology | Single-phase suction (Expression phase only). | 2-Phase Expression Technology (Stimulation & Expression phases). |
| Efficiency | Effective, but may take longer for milk let-down and expression. | More efficient and faster milk expression by mimicking natural nursing patterns. |
| Comfort | Consistent suction level throughout. | Improved comfort with initial faster, lighter suction for stimulation, followed by deeper, slower suction for expression. |
βοΈ Alternatives vs MEDELA Pump In Style Advanced
| Aspect | Spectra S2 Plus | Lansinoh Smartpump 2.0 | MEDELA Pump In Style Advanced |
|---|---|---|---|
| System Type | Closed System | Closed System | Open System |
| Noise Level | Very Quiet | Relatively Quiet | Audible |
| Suction Customization | Highly Customizable (Cycle & Vacuum) | Customizable (Cycle & Vacuum) | Pre-set levels, less granular customization |
| Portability | Requires power outlet (S1 has battery) | Portable with app integration | Good portability with battery pack and tote/backpack |
| Breast Shield Material | Silicone/Plastic | Silicone/Plastic | Hard Plastic |
| Ease of Cleaning | Relatively straightforward (fewer parts to clean due to closed system) | Straightforward (fewer parts to clean due to closed system) | Requires careful attention to prevent milk into tubing (open system) |
π‘ FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)
- Is the Medela Pump In Style Advanced an open or closed system? The Medela Pump In Style Advanced is an open-system breast pump. This means that milk can potentially enter the tubing and motor, so diligent cleaning and proper part replacement are important.
- Can I use the Pump In Style Advanced without an electrical outlet? Yes, the Pump In Style Advanced includes a battery pack that allows it to be used with 8 AA batteries for portable pumping when an electrical outlet is not available.
- How often should I replace the pump parts? It is generally recommended to replace membranes every 2-4 weeks, valves every 1-2 months, and tubing every 3-6 months or if any mold or damage is visible, depending on frequency of use and proper cleaning.
- Are the breast shields BPA-free? Yes, all Medela breast milk collection and feeding products that come into contact with breast milk are made without BPA.
π Positive Reviews - What Users Love
- The 2-Phase Expression technology really makes a difference in getting milk faster and more comfortably compared to other pumps I've tried. It mimics my baby's suckling well.
- This pump is a workhorse; I've used it daily for months and it still has strong suction. It's very reliable for consistent pumping sessions.
- I appreciate the convenience of the tote bag and the cooler. It makes it easy to carry everything I need for pumping at work.
- Being able to switch between wall power and batteries is a lifesaver for on-the-go pumping or during power outages.
- Finding replacement parts is incredibly easy, which is a huge plus for maintaining the pump over time.
π Negative Reviews - What Could Be Better
- The noise level is quite noticeable, especially if you're trying to pump discreetly in an office or near a sleeping baby. It's definitely not a quiet pump.
- Cleaning the tubing is a concern since it's an open system. I'm always worried about moisture or milk getting into the motor.
- While the bag is helpful, the pump itself is still quite bulky and heavy. It's not as compact or lightweight as some of the newer, smaller pumps on the market.
- I wish it had more customizable suction settings. Sometimes the pre-set levels feel too strong or not quite strong enough for optimal comfort and output.
- The hard plastic breast shields can feel less comfortable than softer silicone flanges offered by other brands.
π Key Details & Specifications
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Pump Type | Double Electric Breast Pump |
| Expression Technology | 2-Phase Expression Technology (Stimulation & Expression phases) |
| System Type | Open System |
| Power Source | AC Power Adapter, Battery Pack (8 AA batteries, not included) |
| Weight (Motor Unit Only) | Approximately 2.3 lbs (1.04 kg) |
| Vacuum Levels | Adjustable within pre-set ranges |
| Included Accessories | Tote Bag/Backpack, Cooler Bag with Ice Pack, Bottles, Breast Shields, Tubing, Connectors |
| BPA-Free | All parts that come into contact with milk are BPA-free |
π Summary β Is This the Right Choice for You?
- The Medela Pump In Style Advanced remains a highly dependable option for mothers who need to express milk regularly, whether for returning to work or building a supply.
- Its proven 2-Phase Expression Technology is effective at mimicking a baby's natural nursing rhythm, often leading to efficient milk expression.
- While its open system design requires diligent cleaning and maintenance, and it can be noisier and bulkier than some newer models, its consistent performance and widespread availability of parts make it a practical choice.
- It's particularly well-suited for those prioritizing strong, reliable suction and the convenience of a portable carrying solution with battery power.
- However, those prioritizing whisper-quiet operation, a closed system for hygiene, or highly customizable suction settings might consider exploring alternative pump models.
