Is this mascara waterproof?

The Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! Mascara is not explicitly marketed as waterproof, but rather as smudge-proof and humidity-proof.

Does this mascara flake?

While designed to be long-wearing, some users have reported minor flaking towards the end of the day, particularly after extended wear.

It features a unique "precision paddle brush" with load-and-lift diamond-shaped bristles, engineered to lift and separate each lash.

Some users find it requires an oil-based or bi-phase makeup remover for complete and easy removal, while others report it can be stubborn to remove.

Aspect	Pros	Cons
Lift & Volume	Users report a noticeable lift and enhanced volume, creating a wide-eyed effect. Many find lashes appear longer and fuller.	Some users find the formula can be too thick, leading to clumping, especially with multiple coats.
Wear & Smudge Resistance	Feedback indicates it is long-wearing and resistant to smudging throughout the day, even in humid conditions.	A subset of users experienced flaking or smudging after several hours, particularly on the lower lash line.
Application & Brush	The unique paddle brush is described by many as effective for separating and lifting lashes from the root.	Some users found the brush design challenging to use, leading to product overload or difficulty reaching inner lashes.
Removal	Can be removed with a gentle oil-based cleanser for many users without excessive rubbing.	A common concern is that the mascara can be stubborn to remove completely, requiring multiple passes or specific makeup removers.

Component/Technology	Why It Matters
Lash-Lifting Polymer	Designed to create a lifting and holding effect for lashes, contributing to the "push-up" claim and long-lasting curl.
Keratin	A protein often included in lash products, intended to condition and strengthen lashes, promoting flexibility.
Unique Paddle Brush with Diamond-Shaped Bristles	Engineered to grip each lash from root to tip, providing an even coat of product, lifting, and separating for maximum volume and length.

Aspect	Positive	Negative
Performance	Many users feel the dramatic results in lift, length, and volume justify the investment, considering it a premium product.	Some users feel that for the price, the potential for clumping or difficulty in removal diminishes its overall value proposition.
Longevity of Product	Users report the formula generally lasts well on the lashes throughout the day, reducing the need for touch-ups.	A few users noted that the product inside the tube seemed to dry out faster than expected for its price point.

Aspect	Dior Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Mascara	Benefit Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara	Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! Mascara
Key Features	Known for its curling effect and volume, often praised for its ability to hold a curl.	Emphasizes a "hook 'n' roll" brush for lash grabbing, separating, and curling without needing an eyelash curler.	Focuses on extreme lift and volume with a unique paddle brush.
Durability	Generally considered long-lasting and resilient to flaking throughout the day.	Provides reliable, all-day wear, resisting smudges and flakes for many.	Offers long-wearing, smudge-resistant performance for most users.
Overall Value	Provides a luxurious experience and consistent performance, justifying its similar price point for many.	Often seen as offering excellent performance for its price, delivering on its curling and lifting claims effectively.	Offers high-impact results, but some may find the premium cost high if issues like clumping occur.

Is this mascara waterproof? The Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! Mascara is not explicitly marketed as waterproof, but rather as smudge-proof and humidity-proof.
Does this mascara flake? While designed to be long-wearing, some users have reported minor flaking towards the end of the day, particularly after extended wear.
What kind of brush does it have? It features a unique "precision paddle brush" with load-and-lift diamond-shaped bristles, engineered to lift and separate each lash.
Is it easy to remove? Some users find it requires an oil-based or bi-phase makeup remover for complete and easy removal, while others report it can be stubborn to remove.

This mascara truly gives a dramatic lift and impressive volume, making my lashes look incredibly long and full without feeling heavy.
I love how black the pigment is; it really defines my eyes and makes them pop.
It holds a curl all day long, which is rare for my straight lashes.
I've worn this through busy days, and it doesn't smudge or flake under my eyes.
The brush separates my lashes beautifully, preventing them from clumping together.

I found this mascara to be quite clumpy, especially if I tried to apply more than one coat, making my lashes stick together.
It's incredibly difficult to remove, even with dedicated eye makeup removers, which sometimes causes lash fallout.
For the price, I expected it to last longer without drying out in the tube.
The brush is a bit awkward to maneuver, especially on my smaller inner lashes, leading to smudges on my eyelid.
I experienced some flaking by the afternoon, which was disappointing for a high-end mascara.

Aspect	Detail
Product Type	Mascara
Volume	10 mL / 0.33 fl oz
Shade	Super Black
Brush Type	Precision Paddle Brush with Load-and-Lift Diamond Bristles
Key Ingredients/Claims	Lash-Lifting Polymer, Keratin, Smudge-proof, Humidity-proof
Targeted Effect	Lift, Lengthen, Volumize

The Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! Mascara aims to deliver significant lift, volume, and length, with a rich black pigment.
Its unique paddle brush and specific formula ingredients are designed to achieve a "push-up" effect and hold a curl.
While many users praise its dramatic results and long-wearing properties, some encounter challenges with potential clumping, application due to the brush design, and difficulty of removal.
It stands out for its strong lifting capabilities.
Consider this mascara if your primary goal is a noticeable lash lift and intense volume, and you are prepared to use a dedicated makeup remover.